diff --git a/Patches/ReloadInPlacePatches.cs b/Patches/ReloadInPlacePatches.cs
index 5e1e2eb..1d6dbce 100644
--- a/Patches/ReloadInPlacePatches.cs
+++ b/Patches/ReloadInPlacePatches.cs
@@ -112,8 +112,8 @@ public static class ReloadInPlacePatches
         [PatchPrefix]
         public static bool Prefix(Player.FirearmController __instance, MagazineClass magazine, ItemAddressClass gridItemAddress)
         {
-            // If gridItemAddress isn't null, it already found a place for the current mag, so let it run
-            if (gridItemAddress != null || !Settings.SwapMags.Value)
+            // If gridItemAddress isn't null, it already found a place for the current mag, so let it run (unless always swap is enabled)
+            if (!Settings.SwapMags.Value || (gridItemAddress != null && !Settings.AlwaysSwapMags.Value))
             {
                 return true;
             }
diff --git a/Settings.cs b/Settings.cs
index 9d4d002..cc77978 100644
--- a/Settings.cs
+++ b/Settings.cs
@@ -82,6 +82,7 @@ internal class Settings
     public static ConfigEntry<bool> ShowMultiSelectDebug { get; set; } // Advanced
     public static ConfigEntry<bool> SwapItems { get; set; }
     public static ConfigEntry<bool> SwapMags { get; set; }
+    public static ConfigEntry<bool> AlwaysSwapMags { get; set; }
     public static ConfigEntry<bool> SwapImpossibleContainers { get; set; }
     public static ConfigEntry<bool> ReorderGrids { get; set; }
     public static ConfigEntry<bool> SynchronizeStashScrolling { get; set; }
@@ -406,7 +407,16 @@ internal class Settings
             "Reload Magazines In-Place",
             true,
             new ConfigDescription(
-                "When reloading a weapon with a magazine, swap locations with the new magazine (if possible)",
+                "When reloading a weapon with a magazine, swap locations with the new magazine if necessary (and possible)",
+                null,
+                new ConfigurationManagerAttributes { })));
+
+        configEntries.Add(AlwaysSwapMags = config.Bind(
+            InventorySection,
+            "Always Reload Magazines In-Place",
+            false,
+            new ConfigDescription(
+                "Always reload magazines in-place, even if there's space not to. Note that in-place reloads are slower.",
                 null,
                 new ConfigurationManagerAttributes { })));